April 24, 2008...10:04 pm
an awkward moment on the bus
Local and regular readers will know this, but my neighbourhood is home to, I think, the largest population of Hassidic Jews outside Brooklyn. Or is it Toronto? Or is it ultra-Orthodox, or Orthodox, of whom the Hassidim, or Chassidim, are only one group? Anyway, let us just say it is a very mixed neighbourhood, with a preponderance of long black coats and hats, and we all seem to rub along pretty well I’d say. I love it.
So there I was on my way home from work, coming over the crest of Stamford Hill on a bendy bus, & I sat down on one of two seats together, next to a young woman. Next stop, the woman sitting on the two seats next to each other across the aisle from me (isn’t English wonderful?) got off, leaving the two seats empty. The girl next to me was chewing gum rather loudly; I thought of moving, but then couldn’t, quite frankly my dear, be arsed - so I stayed where I was.
Just then a little boy got on, small & thin, milk-pale, maybe ten, with his long blond side curls very thoroughly tucked in under his yarmulke (his mother’s done that, I bet - they were so tight, I found myself having a train of thought about whether that’s the rule for him going out on his own, because unfortunately we don’t all rub along that well), and a serious expression on his face. He sat, or sort of perched, on the outside of the two seats across the aisle from me.
Next stop: on gets a stout middle-aged black lady with her bag of shopping, and makes to sit on the inner one of the two seats, that is, the opposite number to the one where the girl is chomping her gum. The boy moves to let her in; she takes her seat by the window; and — guess what. He goes over to the other side and stands there, nervously and uncomfortably, holding on to the pole. He is frowning. Why did he get up to let the lady in and then not sit back down? She’s not that large - I mean, there’s room. Is it because he’s been imbued with racist ideas about non-Jews, or even about black people? Is it because she’s a woman? Is it just because he’s a little boy and she’s a large person pushing sixty?
He looks full of consternation but beyond that it is hard to read.
I am surprised; the middle-aged black lady, clearly a matriarch herself, not unlike the worthy ladies Kei Miller writes his lovely poems about and not in the habit of being spurned by children, is surprised. She looks at me. I look away with an expression both mournful and non-committal, and glance at the boy: he’s leaning nervously on a rail, worrying at his lower lip. The lady sits on the seat, not wanting to look like someone who’d kick a kid off a seat. At my stop she looks at me again. I don’t really feel like meeting her eye over this - after all, he is just a kid, & it’s unclear - so I make a little mouth and try to look sympathetic from afar as I step out into the air.
Hmm. Sad, though. Because no matter what the little drama was about, it didn’t leave anybody feeling any happier.

14 Comments
April 24, 2008 at 10:37 pm
Great post. Good story telling.
BA
April 24, 2008 at 11:05 pm
It might be more of an issue of gender (versus color). (Click my name.)
April 24, 2008 at 11:24 pm
Thanks Brian, and welcome!
Jilly, that is very interesting, and depressing. Even more depressingly it could still be either. Thanks for the fascinating link. (NPR, I’ll also add, is under threat from lack of funding.)
April 25, 2008 at 12:55 am
Isn’t it true that children can do opaqueness like no-one else; just as they can do transparency like no-one else. Race, gender, age, color — all possibilities here, although I have to say that my first thought was that the lady somehow violated some private-inside-child scenario — something vaguely like this..?
http://www.poemhunter.com/poem/lines-and-squares/
Whatever the case, thanks for sharing, Nic
April 25, 2008 at 9:13 am
A fabulous little snapshot of life in London. I see a dozen fascinating little incidents of human behaviour like this every week.
Don’t you hate those bendy buses? And don’t you wish that the concertina bit in the middle made a sound like an accordian when it bellows in and out? I’m sure it would cheer everyone up on their way to work.
Great writing and a nice shiny new blogspace.
April 25, 2008 at 9:19 am
Nicely done, Ms B.
April 25, 2008 at 11:33 am
Perfectly observed, perfectly told.
April 25, 2008 at 1:24 pm
I’d assume it was a mixture of both. Even I (i’m 13) would feel strange sitting next to a complete stranger. Suppose its his first time catching the bus? or even if he is used to the bus route maybe he was just being a kind boy and letting another citizen sit in his seat, as he is an able bodied child? But if that was not the case, i would suppose it would be the whole ‘Race’ issue. I live in Australia, and I have a Jewish friend, now, I don’t think she is really strict, but if I say, perhaps about a certain teacher that I dislike, I may accidentally without knowing say, ‘What a nazi’. I then get this stare of despair right at my face, because I completely forgot. She doesn’t care if im her close friend, its what shes been brought up with and I suppose religion comes first.
Nice story, I’ve seen this happen before too. But not in the same circumstances.
April 25, 2008 at 5:37 pm
It’s also possible it was a matter or ritual purity. I’m no expert but I Hassidic Jews do observe several Talmudic laws including some regarding contact with women, particularly if they might be menstruating. While we all know a 60-ish woman is not likely to be menstruating, a 10 year old boy probably does not. He may only have a vague idea as to how to apply the ritual purity laws.
April 26, 2008 at 12:39 am
I think grinningthorn has probably gotten it as close to right as anyone outside the little boy’s community of faith could.
I truly hope that it is this kind of thin and not where our minds automatically go—the race issue.
I would be willing to bet that it is a gender issue at the very most.
April 26, 2008 at 10:07 am
You may be making too much of this. Gender issues, race issues… Give him a chance. The boy is ten and shy and maybe a bit scared. He doesn’t quite know how to deal with sitting next to strangers. Isn’t that possible?
April 27, 2008 at 1:05 pm
I was in an airport departure lounge once when a chap in a long coat and all the works began circulating asking each passenger individually if they were jewish. when he got to the man sitting oppsite me the reply, in a irish accent, was ‘no, are you catholic?’. well, you had to be there…
April 27, 2008 at 8:46 pm
George, you are absolutely right, and it should have been said earlier. He IS just a kid, and shouldn’t be dragged into all that grown-up infantile BS. I still think Katy’s story was perfectly told though, one of those moments when no one seems to know what to say or where to look or what to think.
April 28, 2008 at 4:27 pm
Couldn’t it be some kind of hygiene issue? Perhaps the child had concerns over his own hygiene, was about to break wind, anything like that. That would explain both why he remained standing once up and why he looked uncomfortable.
Or perhaps, once he moved, he realised that he would rather stand – again for any one a number of possible reasons. He had cramp. He wasn’t sure where his stop was and wanted a better vantage point. Pick your hypothesis.
I’m uncomfortable with assuming that it ‘must be race’, ‘must be gender’, ‘must be religion’. I doubt it’s any of those (only my personal opinion).
Nice blog, by the way. Hello.
Leave a Reply