October 22, 2008...8:28 am

books and freedom: 2 or, elegantly dressed banned in Hackney

Jump to Comments

The writer Iain Sinclair, with whom I am proud to share Hackney, is a “non-person.” The worst thing about that epithet is that he may have thought of it himself, but it describes a situation he certainly didn’t choose. He has been banned in Hackney.

Yes! Our rose-red empire. Home to the Dissenters themselves, the borough that gave us Diane Abbott.

A year ago Sinclair was invited to launch his new novel, coincidentally entitled Hackney, That Rose-Red Empire, at Stoke Newington Library. (Mind you, I have known just how useless they are there ever since my then-2-year-old was allowed tp push his pushchair out of the building and into the street, straight past the front desk, which sits by the door – from a children’s story hour! I had turned my back, knowing what the child was like, for precisely one minute, and was eight months pregnant at the time. I discovered him, with no help from the librarians, way up Church St heading confidently for the park. We never went back. Basically, I banned the story hour.)

Even though he was horrified that the library’s local history section had shrunk to a carrier bag of pamphlets under the counter, Sinclair accepted the invitation and has been planning ever since to launch his book in this historic and highly local venue.

“Hackney Libraries invited me to come back in February 2009,” Sinclair writes, “to launch a book I had been working on for more years than I care to remember: Hackney, That Rose-Red Empire. I was happy to accept, believing that a work researched, contrived and constructed in this place should have its first reading right here. A small return on my part for 40 years of madness and inspiration, painting the white lines of football pitches on Hackney Marshes or trawling for used books in Kingsland Waste Market…”

But how things can turn. Yesterday he related on the Today programme, and this morning recaps in the Guardian, the news that this invitation has been withdrawn. He has been told that he would be an “inappropriate” choice for a book launch in a Hackney library. He’s too “controversial.” Too controversial for a library! And why? Because in June he criticised the Olympics in the Times Literary Supplement. (As someone said, the council seems to be a bit behind in its reading.)

The Olympics: car parks and shopping malls and the loss of our open spaces, historic Hackney Marshes, and the way it’s selling local people down the river (Lea). Apparently, if you talk about the 2012 Olympics at all in this part of town, you have to praise it.

According to the council, if you criticise the Olympics, you are relinquish the privilege of undertaking any public use of their buildings, resources, or indeed goodwill, even if it is in a completely different capacity from your criticism of the Olympics. No citizen who publicly dislikes the Olympics, in short, may enjoy the public support of the council for any other reason at all.

When I first lived in Stoke Newington and used the library all the time, its foyer proudly displayed the gravestone of Daniel Defoe himself. I used to show it to my infants every week (sadly, this is true), telling them what an honour it was to grow up in the home of this man, father of the English novel and champion of free speech. (Indefatigable pamphleteer, in fact; I hope it wasn’t his pamphlets in that carrier bag.)

So here it is, Elegantly Dressed Wednesday – which, for people who missed the first chapter, was started by the prolific, and politically engaged, Hackney blogger Ben Locker. An excellent opportunity to admire Iain Sinclair’s black-on-black arrangement above – the honest, intelligent simplicity of his T shirt, the jauntiness of his button-down shirt-collar, and the clarity of his spectacles. He can see things council officers can’t; he can say things council officers can’t; and that is only elegant.

Repeat after me: Sha bi!

11 Comments

  • I hoped you’d post on this. Something tells me that this latest persecution of a thought criminal will go unreported in the pages of Hackney Today.

    Why don’t we organise a special “Why I hate Hackney Council” poetry/prose reading, featuring any local resident capable of stringing a sentence together. What do you say?

  • Ha! This post resonated with me because I got an email this morning from the editor of the (to me) desperately uncritical “cultural arts” magazine Aesthetica objecting to an “unnecessarily harsh” recent post on my blog.

    I find it disturbing that we seem to be living in an age where we’re encouraged to follow the rule “if you can’t say something nice, don’t say anything at all”. As a critic, do you think this is increasingly the case?

    By the way, what does “blogger-in-residence” at the Southbank involve? Do you get an office an’ all? Or will you be feverishly typing on stage and doing blogging workshops for the public? If so, we’ll try and pop by! Perhaps I can buy you a coffee on your break?

  • Hi Ms B

    As you know, the old House of Pants was adjacent to the Olympics site and I’m so glad I left before this money-munching menace got seriously underway. I could see it causing only misery. Hackney Council has always been hyper-sensitive to any kind of critical questioning, preferring to believe that those who are just trying to understand how seemingly idiotic decisions get made are lecherous traitors bent on spoiling everyone else’s fun.

    xxx

    Pants

  • I obtained a fuller explanation of this decision from the Council yesterday.

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/davehillblog/2008/oct/22/olympics2012-london

    Still doesn’t convince me, I’m afraid.

  • It comes to something when libraries censor freedom of speech – they are, after all, in the process of rebranding themselves as “ideas centres”…

    I am usually a fan of Stoke Newington library (because it has lots of old Women’s Press editions and doesn’t have a TV on at full volume like my local one), but if they’re going to start behaving like press officers, we’re all in trouble. Will they now start checking all the books they bring in, in case some of them criticise something another person might think is quite good? Throw out the entire political section, in case people read Noam Chomsky and get ideas?

  • [...] to Missy B Posted in Anti Social Behaviour, Councils, Hackney, Idiots, [...]

  • Clare, I couldn’t agree more. I checked out a fellow blogger’s blog today, knowing I had left a comment there a few days ago in which I had questioned the talent of a currently “popular” writer and poet about whom he had blogged. Lo and behold, my comment had been suppressed, even though it was exceptionally mild and was indeed merely a passing one-liner. Other comments had been published, however. All of them unquestioningly positive.

    I have now removed that blog from my Best Of blogroll. There is something spineless – and sometimes even sycophantic – about people who can admit no criticisms or negative comments into their blogs, just in case someone is offended.

    If I took the ‘positive reviews only, thanks’ approach as an editor, my magazine wouldn’t be worth reading and I’d be quite rightly given the boot. And the same goes for bloggers who lack the courage to risk offence in the name of honest debate.

    Hackney Council, listen up!

  • Anghard Stevens

    Surely you, and not Hackney Council, are responsible for looking after your own 2 year old in a library? I was looking for information on the Baroque when I stumbled on this whingelog. It’s quite amusing in a Pooterish way. How fat you look in your photo!

  • Thanks Anghard. Lovely to meet you, too. Now, I certainly don’t have to explain myself to you, whoever you are, but as a matter of record I’ll just say that I was in fact there with TWO children. There is such a thing as health and safety. My guard may have been down due to the fact that that I thought I was in a child-friendly space… certainly if we’d been in a shop or something I’d have had him holding my hand, but that would rather defeat the object of a play session, wouldn’t it?

    How many kids do you have? I’m interested.

    And you’re right: I am really very fat indeed.

    Have a great day!

  • What a rude person. How very stupid he sounds in his blog post.

    I’ve lost several children in libraries over the years. They were all restored to me eventually, but losing them is easily done, even during events geared towards toddlers. One of mine also left the building on one occasion, unnoticed apparently by any adults, although there were plenty around at the time.

    Now, when I see a very small child heading out of a public library unaccompanied, which does occasionally happen, I never fail to challenge the intrepid young person thus: ‘Hey, shortie, where are you going? Where’s your mum/dad/parent?’ and then shoo them back inside in search of a librarian or security person with a walkie-talkie.

    But public libraries, it seems, are full of people who are perfectly oblivious to the sight of a determined toddler heading off to carve his/her own way in the world. Because like you I had to retrieve all my own children unaided. And when you have five, as I do, keeping track of them all is no easy matter.


Leave a Reply